Throughput, limits and the scale of the economy
Ecological economics treats the economy as part of the biosphere. Kenneth Boulding's essay 'The Economics of the Coming Spaceship Earth' (1966) gave the field its best-known image, the earth as a spaceship [1], and Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen's The Entropy Law and the Economic Process (1971) read production through the entropy law of thermodynamics [2]. Ecological macroeconomics came later: Rezai and Stagl note that ecological economists mostly studied small-scale parts of the economy, Boulding and Georgescu-Roegen being early exceptions, and that interest in the macroeconomic level has been growing [3].
In 1972 The Limits to Growth, a study begun at MIT in 1970, concluded that the earth's interlocking resources probably could not support the present rates of economic and population growth much beyond 2100, even with advanced technology [4]. Herman Daly's Steady-State Economics (1977) turned the argument toward a steady-state economy built on the view that 'enough is best' [5].
Modern evidence gives the argument numbers. Between 1992 and 2014, produced capital per person doubled worldwide and human capital per person rose by about 13 percent, while natural capital per person fell by nearly 40 percent; accumulating produced and human capital at the expense of natural capital, the review observes, is what growth and development have come to mean for many people [6]. Economic productivity peaks at an average annual temperature of about 13°C and declines strongly above it; if future adaptation mimics past adaptation, unmitigated warming would reduce average global incomes by roughly 23 percent by 2100 and widen income inequality between countries [7]. Energy is the oldest macro channel: all but one US recession from the Second World War to the early 1980s followed a sharp rise in the price of oil, although Hamilton was careful to say that the correlation alone does not show oil caused them [8].
The central dispute is decoupling: can output grow while resource use and emissions fall? Counting the raw materials embodied in trade, the material footprint of nations rises by about 6 percent for every 10 percent rise in GDP, and advanced economies' decoupling is smaller than reported or absent [9]. A review of trends and projections finds no evidence that absolute decoupling of resource use can be achieved globally alongside continued growth [10]. Tim Jackson asks how employment and financial stability could be kept without growth [11], and Kate Raworth's 'doughnut' sets a social foundation drawn from the Sustainable Development Goals beneath an environmental ceiling of nine planetary boundaries, with an environmentally safe and socially just space between them [12]. This guide's test is whether a named physical constraint binds at the scale being studied.