Robert Hodrick and Edward Prescott circulated their filter as a Carnegie Mellon working paper in 1980, though the published version appeared in the Journal of Money, Credit and Banking only in 1997. The idea is simple: decompose a time series yt into a trend τt and a cyclical residual ct=yt−τt by finding the trend that minimizes a weighted sum of fit (how close τt stays to yt) and smoothness (how small the second differences of τt are). The single tuning parameter λ controls the trade-off: λ=0 reproduces the original series, λ→∞ yields a linear time trend. Kydland and Prescott (1990) popularized λ=1600 for quarterly data in the real business cycle literature, and the filter became the default detrending tool across central banks, international organizations, and academic macro.
Beveridge and Nelson (1981) took a fundamentally different approach. Rather than imposing an external smoother, they showed that any I(1) process with a stationary first difference can be decomposed into a random walk with drift (the permanent component) plus a stationary residual (the transitory component). The permanent component equals the series plus the sum of all expected future changes net of the mean drift - the level the series would reach if it immediately converged to its long-run forecast path; the transitory component is minus that sum. No tuning parameter is needed. The decomposition follows directly from the Wold representation of the first-differenced series, which in practice means fitting an ARIMA model and computing cumulative impulse responses.
The two methods produce strikingly different decompositions in practice. The HP filter yields a smooth trend and a sizable, persistent cycle, which aligns with the RBC tradition's view of large transitory business-cycle fluctuations. The BN decomposition typically yields a volatile trend and a small, quickly-reverting cycle, because the permanent component absorbs most of the series' variation. This tension was clarified by Morley, Nelson, and Zivot (2003), who showed that the standard UCM with uncorrelated trend-cycle shocks maps to the HP filter's smooth-trend result, while the unrestricted UCM with correlated shocks maps to the BN decomposition's volatile-trend result. The difference is not about method but about whether trend and cycle innovations are allowed to covary.
Hamilton (2018) mounted a forceful critique of the HP filter, documenting its tendency to create spurious cyclical dynamics in integrated or near-integrated data. He proposed a regression-based alternative: regress yt+h on yt,yt−1,yt−2,yt−3 and take the residual as the cycle. The Hamilton filter avoids end-point bias by construction (it uses only past data), but it targets a specific forecast horizon h rather than extracting a smooth trend. The debate between HP advocates, BN practitioners, and Hamilton-filter proponents remains active. Each method answers a subtly different question about what 'trend' means.