A reduced-form VAR estimates a set of forecast-error covariance matrices and moving-average coefficients, but those objects are silent about causation. The residual vector ut bundles every contemporaneous structural disturbance into a single composite innovation for each variable. Sims (1980) proposed the VAR framework to let the data speak, but extracting economic stories - a monetary policy shock, an oil supply disruption, a technology impulse - requires additional restrictions that map the reduced-form residuals ut into orthogonal structural shocks εt. That mapping is the identification problem. This model extends the reduced-form VAR, already documented in the VAR page of this platform.
The core issue is algebraic. A VAR with n variables has a reduced-form covariance matrix Σu with n(n+1)/2 unique elements. The structural impact matrix B0−1 that maps εt into ut via ut=B0−1εt has n2 free parameters. The orthogonality assumption E[εtεt′]=In delivers Σu=B0−1B0−1′, which supplies n(n+1)/2 equations for n2 unknowns. The gap is n(n−1)/2 restrictions that must come from economic theory, institutional knowledge, or external data. Every identification scheme - recursive ordering, sign restrictions, narrative instruments, long-run neutrality, heteroskedasticity-based approaches - fills exactly this gap.
Recursive identification (Cholesky decomposition of Σu) imposes a causal ordering: variables ordered earlier cannot respond contemporaneously to shocks hitting variables ordered later. Sims (1980) and Christiano, Eichenbaum, and Evans (1999) used recursive structures to study monetary policy. Sign restrictions (Uhlig 2005; Faust 1998) replace zero restrictions with inequality constraints on impulse-response signs over specified horizons, accepting set identification rather than point identification. External instruments / proxy SVAR (Stock and Watson 2012; Mertens and Ravn 2013) use an outside variable correlated with one structural shock but uncorrelated with the others, recovering the column of B0−1 associated with that shock via instrumental variables on the reduced-form residuals.
Central banks and academic researchers lean on SVAR identification daily. Kilian (2009, American Economic Review) used a recursive SVAR in global crude oil production, global real economic activity, and the real price of oil to separate oil supply shocks from aggregate-demand and oil-specific-demand shocks. ECB staff research uses sign restrictions to study euro-area monetary transmission (for example, Jarociński and Karadi 2020, who combine them with high-frequency surprises to separate policy shocks from central-bank information shocks). Academic work on fiscal multipliers (Blanchard and Perotti 2002) uses institutional timing to identify government spending shocks. Proxy SVARs have become a standard way to identify monetary policy shocks after Gertler and Karadi (2015) demonstrated the approach using high-frequency futures surprises as instruments.