Why are imports subtracted from GDP?
Separate foreign production from domestic value added.
- Open
- GDP → Follow a purchase
- Compare
- Direct import / Import + domestic service
- Read
- Final Household purchase stage
1Predict, test and explain
1. Predict 3 min
A household spends 100 on a good made abroad, with no domestic service. Predict the amounts recorded in C, M, and domestic GDP. Explain your prediction before opening the completed example.
2. Follow the purchase 4 min
Inspect the direct-import example. Record the household’s spending and the foreign content. Explain why recording C alone would count foreign production as domestic output.
3. Add a domestic service 5 min
Switch to Import + domestic service. The household now pays 120 for a good imported for 100. Use spending, value added, and the 12 of employee compensation plus 8 of operating surplus to explain the domestic contribution.
4. Explain the difference 5 min
Write two sentences distinguishing an accounting subtraction from a claim about the economic effects of trade. Identify information this transaction cannot tell you about welfare or jobs.
2Record your results
| Completed purchase | Consumption C | Imports M | Domestic GDP contribution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Direct import: purchase price 100; foreign content 100 | |||
| Import + domestic service: price 120; foreign content 100 |
3Bring it back to the class
Why would counting the entire 120 as domestic output overstate GDP?
Where does the retailer’s 20 appear in the production and income approaches?
Would the identity alone tell us what happens to GDP if a country stops importing? What else would have to be specified?