Cookies on Macro by Mark.We use essential cookies for sign-in, locale, and security. With your permission, we also use optional cookies for preferences, for analytics, and for advertising measurement with the Meta (Facebook) Pixel. Read our cookie policy.
Distinguish a demand expansion from an adverse supply shock by their effects on real output and the price level, while stating the selected short-run assumptions.
Before you begin
Aggregate demand, short-run aggregate supply, potential output, and reading an equilibrium diagram.
One baseline. Two separate shocks.Linear short-run supply
Demand experimentAD₀ 176 → 188Keep SRAS fixed
Supply experimentAS₀ 5 → 13Reset demand first
AD P = 176 − 0.9YSRAS P = 5 + 0.9YPotential Y* = 95
Your starting point
Set up the experiment
Baseline
AD₀ = 176 · AS₀ = 5
Hold fixed
Both slopes = 0.9 · Y* = 95
Run separately
AD₀ → 188 / AS₀ → 13
Step-by-step setup
Open the AD–AS graph and use Reset parameters in Controls. Use the default upward-sloping linear SRAS, not the alternative Keynesian reverse-L convention.
Check AD intercept = 176, AD slope = 0.9, SRAS intercept = 5, SRAS slope = 0.9, and potential output = 95. These are normalized teaching units.
For the demand experiment, change only the AD intercept to 188. Reset before the supply experiment, then change only the SRAS intercept to 13. Leave both slopes and potential output fixed.
Assumptions and unitsThis is a static, short-run linear AD–AS comparison: P = AD₀ − 0.9Y and P = AS₀ + 0.9Y. Potential output remains 95. P is a price-level index, not an inflation rate. The graph does not calculate a calendar-time adjustment path.
Notation
Y
Real output, in the graph’s normalized units
P
Price-level index (not an inflation rate)
Y*
Potential output, shown by the vertical LRAS line
AD₀
The AD intercept control: the price level on the AD curve at Y = 0
AS₀
The SRAS intercept control: the price index on the SRAS curve at Y = 0
Student worksheet
Predict first, then compare your reasoning with the model.
1
Predict both shocks
4 min
Sketch the baseline. Before moving a control, predict the direction of output and the price level after a demand expansion and after a higher production-cost shock.
2
Change demand
6 min
Raise only the AD intercept (AD₀) from 176 to 188. Record the new output and price level. Explain the movement along the unchanged short-run supply curve.
3
Change supply
6 min
Reset to the same baseline, then raise only the SRAS intercept (AS₀) from 5 to 13. Record the new output and price level. Explain why the output response differs from the demand experiment.
4
Interpret with care
6 min
Compare the two results. Both raise the price level: explain what output adds to the diagnosis, and why a real-world price increase alone does not identify its cause.
Record your results
Scenario
Output Y
Price index P
Direction from baseline
Baseline: AD₀ = 176, AS₀ = 5
Space for your answer
Space for your answer
Space for your answer
Demand expansion: AD₀ = 188, AS₀ = 5
Space for your answer
Space for your answer
Space for your answer
Cost push: AD₀ = 176, AS₀ = 13
Space for your answer
Space for your answer
Space for your answer
Bring it back to the class
Why do both experiments raise P but move Y in different directions?
What changes if the short-run supply convention changes?
Which additional evidence would you want before diagnosing an actual episode?
Write your explanation on the back of this worksheet or on a separate sheet. This activity does not submit or save answers.
Instructor notes and suggested answers
Preview these examples before class. They are authored teaching scenarios, not historical observations or an assessment of student performance.
Worked answers to the steps
Baseline
Equating 176 − 0.9Y with 5 + 0.9Y gives Y = 95 and P = 90.5. Output equals the fixed potential-output benchmark.
Demand expansion
Y = (188 − 5) / 1.8 ≈ 101.67 and P = 96.5. Both output and the price level rise. Output exceeds the unchanged potential benchmark in this short-run comparison.
Cost push
Y = (176 − 13) / 1.8 ≈ 90.56 and P = 94.5. Output falls while the price level rises. The short-run supply curve shifts up and left; this is not a movement along an unchanged supply curve.
Interpretation
These signs follow from the chosen linear schedules with one intercept changed at a time. Multiple shocks can occur together in reality. A price-level comparison is not a calculated inflation rate, and static intersections do not establish the speed or order of adjustment.
Model answers to the discussion questions
Why do both experiments raise P but move Y in different directions?
The demand expansion moves the economy up along the unchanged SRAS curve, so output and the price level rise together: Y ≈ 101.67 and P = 96.5. The cost push shifts SRAS up, so the economy moves up along the unchanged AD curve: the price level rises to 94.5 while output falls to about 90.56. Output, not the price level, separates the two causes.
What changes if the short-run supply convention changes?
How a shock splits between output and the price level depends on the shape of SRAS. A steeper SRAS sends more of a demand expansion into P and less into Y; a flatter one does the reverse. In the graph’s Keynesian mode, a reverse-L schedule, the price level is fixed below capacity and output is capped at potential, so a demand shift changes only Y below capacity and only P once output reaches potential. The worksheet’s numbers hold only for the linear SRAS with slope 0.9.
Which additional evidence would you want before diagnosing an actual episode?
Evidence on what moved, and in which order: real output and employment (rising with prices points to demand, falling points to a supply shock), input costs such as energy prices, import prices and wages, and spending such as consumption and investment. It also helps to know whether the price increases were broad or concentrated in a few goods. Real episodes often combine several shocks, so the evidence can point to a mix.
Listen for these misconceptions
Calling the price index an inflation rate.
Leaving the demand shock in place when starting the separate supply experiment.
Treating a short-run crossing above potential as permanently higher productive capacity.
Take the discussion further
Keep the demand-expanded AD curve and discuss what would need to change for output to return to potential. Identify the additional assumption required before treating that comparison as an adjustment mechanism.
If the simulator is unavailable
Print the student worksheet. Use the stated inputs and equations to work through the same scenarios on paper, then sketch or explain the predicted change. The instructor answers above provide the worked results.
Macro by Mark · Activity revision: 3 November 2026. Suggested timing is a planning estimate; adapt it to your class.
Macro by MarkSuggested class time · 20–25 minutes
Demand shock or supply shock?
Distinguish two reasons for a higher price level.
NameDate
One baseline. Two separate shocks.Linear short-run supply
Demand experimentAD₀ 176 → 188Keep SRAS fixed
Supply experimentAS₀ 5 → 13Reset demand first
AD P = 176 − 0.9YSRAS P = 5 + 0.9YPotential Y* = 95
Baseline
AD₀ = 176 · AS₀ = 5
Hold fixed
Both slopes = 0.9 · Y* = 95
Run separately
AD₀ → 188 / AS₀ → 13
1Predict, test and explain
1. Predict both shocks 4 min
Sketch the baseline. Before moving a control, predict the direction of output and the price level after a demand expansion and after a higher production-cost shock.
2. Change demand 6 min
Raise only the AD intercept (AD₀) from 176 to 188. Record the new output and price level. Explain the movement along the unchanged short-run supply curve.
3. Change supply 6 min
Reset to the same baseline, then raise only the SRAS intercept (AS₀) from 5 to 13. Record the new output and price level. Explain why the output response differs from the demand experiment.
4. Interpret with care 6 min
Compare the two results. Both raise the price level: explain what output adds to the diagnosis, and why a real-world price increase alone does not identify its cause.
2Record your results
Worksheet results
Scenario
Output Y
Price index P
Direction from baseline
Baseline: AD₀ = 176, AS₀ = 5
Demand expansion: AD₀ = 188, AS₀ = 5
Cost push: AD₀ = 176, AS₀ = 13
3Bring it back to the class
Why do both experiments raise P but move Y in different directions?
What changes if the short-run supply convention changes?
Which additional evidence would you want before diagnosing an actual episode?