需要考虑的证据
先看度量
如果不清楚度量的对象是什么——产出、收入、价格、就业、信贷、预期还是福利——学派之间的对比就站不住脚。
核查要点
- 写明所度量的变量,以及统计机构或数据集。
- 核查修订、频率、季节调整,以及该序列是名义值还是实际值。
- 追问所争论的概念是直接观测到的,还是从模型中推断出来的。
需要避免的错误
- 不要把 GDP 当作福利。
- 如果一方用 CPI、另一方用 PCE 或 HICP 却没有说明,就不要比较双方关于通胀的说法。
Macro by Mark 的 Cookie.我们使用必要 Cookie 处理登录、语言和安全。经您同意,我们还会将可选 Cookie 用于保存偏好、分析,以及通过 Meta(Facebook)Pixel 衡量广告效果。请阅读我们的Cookie 政策。
辩论包
概念告诉你发生了什么。这个工作区回答下一个问题:为什么不同的宏观传统对同一变化有不同读法,以及这些读法导向哪些政策直觉。
先把问题定下来。之后让各行始终并列展示。
对比观点
通过核查度量指标、因果关系的证据以及政策变化传导到经济的方式,权衡相互竞争的解释。
需要考虑的证据
如果不清楚度量的对象是什么——产出、收入、价格、就业、信贷、预期还是福利——学派之间的对比就站不住脚。
核查要点
需要避免的错误
需要考虑的证据
难点通常不在于发生了什么,而在于如果冲击、利率路径、财政立场或制度不同,会发生什么。
核查要点
需要避免的错误
需要考虑的证据
任何关于政策或冲击的说法都需要一个渠道:收入、替代、信贷、预期、资产负债表、汇率、加成或供给能力。
核查要点
需要避免的错误
当前辩论包
通胀争论 会让学派行和情景视角保持对齐,你可以直接切换比较内容,而不必手动重建页面状态。
学派
当前预设:通胀争论。最多选三家学派,让同样几行辩论一直贯穿整页。
Mainstream
Heterodox
Other traditions
什么导致衰退?
Monetarist
打开Often reflect monetary tightening, unstable money growth, or policy mistakes.
New Keynesian
打开Can arise when demand weakens and rigid prices or wages slow adjustment.
Modern Heterogeneous-Agent Macro
打开Become more severe when constrained households and fragile balance sheets cut spending quickly.
什么导致通胀?
Monetarist
打开Sustained inflation ultimately requires excessive money growth or permissive monetary policy.
New Keynesian
打开Moves through expectations, marginal costs, and sticky nominal adjustment.
Modern Heterogeneous-Agent Macro
打开Transmission differs across households, sectors, rents, wages, and financing positions.
市场会自我修正吗?
政策什么时候有效?
会使用哪些模型?
接到政策
从相互冲突的诊断,顺势走到它们各自指向的政策领域。
情景
价格在短期内明显加速上涨。
Monetarist
Start with whether money and nominal demand were allowed to outpace real capacity.
New Keynesian
Ask how expectations, costs, and demand pressure interact through sticky-price adjustment.
Modern Heterogeneous-Agent Macro
Look at who faces the price shock, who has buffers, and how expectations differ across households.
原始发布、中央银行材料、官方统计机构及其他机构文件。
[S1] U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis
Reference for U.S. national income and product account concepts, classifications, sources, and methods.
原始与官方来源 - U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis
[S2] U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
Reference for CPI scope, index construction, adjustment, and interpretation limits.
原始与官方来源 - U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
[S3] United Nations Statistics Division
International statistical standard for national accounts.
原始与官方来源 - United Nations Statistics Division
[S4] Federal Reserve
Federal Reserve policy-framework statements and historical revisions.
原始与官方来源 - Federal Reserve
[S5] OECD
Cross-country short-term projections, risks, policy options, and statistical annex references.
原始与官方来源 - OECD
[S6] Bank for International Settlements
Monetary and financial system risks, global financial cycles, and policy tradeoffs.
原始与官方来源 - Bank for International Settlements
[S7] European Central Bank
ECB mandate, strategy, inflation-target framing, and analytical framework.
原始与官方来源 - European Central Bank - 日期 2021
[S8] International Monetary Fund
IMF WEO conventions, projection treatment, revisions, and cross-source caveats.
原始与官方来源 - International Monetary Fund
[S9] U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, retrieved from FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis
Seasonally adjusted. The rate peaked at 10.8 percent in November and December 1982; annual averages were 3.5 percent in 1969 and 8.5 percent in 1975.
原始与官方来源 - U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, retrieved from FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis - 日期 monthly, data to October 2026
[S10] U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, retrieved from FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis
Not seasonally adjusted. Twelve-month inflation was 14.8 percent in March 1980, 3.8 percent in December 1982 and 9.1 percent in June 2022.
原始与官方来源 - U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, retrieved from FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis - 日期 monthly, data to October 2026
[S11] George T. McCandless Jr. and Warren E. Weber, Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Quarterly Review 19(3)
Long-run correlations for 110 countries, 1960 to 1990: money growth and inflation move almost one for one; money growth and real output growth are uncorrelated in the full sample.
原始与官方来源 - George T. McCandless Jr. and Warren E. Weber, Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Quarterly Review 19(3) - 日期 1995
[S12] Gary Richardson, Federal Reserve History
The Federal Reserve's own history: from the fall of 1930 through the winter of 1933 the money supply fell by nearly 30 percent. From the fall of 1930 through the winter of 1933 the money supply fell by nearly 30 percent; the Fed failed to stem the decline. Accessed 2026-11-14.
原始与官方来源 - Gary Richardson, Federal Reserve History - 日期 essay, Federal Reserve History
[S13] Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences
The Nobel citation credits Phelps with the expectations-augmented Phillips curve. Accessed 2026-11-14.
原始与官方来源 - Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences - 日期 2006
[S14] Ben S. Bernanke
Bernanke endorsed Friedman and Schwartz's account of the Fed's role in the Great Depression (remarks of 8 November 2002). Accessed 2026-11-14.
原始与官方来源 - Ben S. Bernanke - 日期 2002
[S15] Ben S. Bernanke
Bernanke described the Fed's failures in the Depression, in monetary policy and as lender of last resort, as lessons for judging its response to the 2008-09 crisis. Accessed 2026-11-14.
原始与官方来源 - Ben S. Bernanke - 日期 2012
为机制和解释提供依据的论文、书籍与研究。
[S16] National Bureau of Economic Research
Business-cycle chronology and dating committee reference.
学术与研究资料 - National Bureau of Economic Research
[S17] Milton Friedman, American Economic Review 58(1)
Presidential address to the American Economic Association, delivered 29 December 1967: the natural rate of unemployment and the case for steady money growth. Friedman defines the natural rate of unemployment, describes the lags of monetary policy and proposes steady growth in a monetary total of something like 3 to 5 percent a year. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Milton Friedman, American Economic Review 58(1) - 日期 1968
[S18] Milton Friedman and Anna J. Schwartz, Princeton University Press for the National Bureau of Economic Research
The empirical foundation of monetarism, including its account of the Great Contraction of 1929-33. Friedman and Schwartz's history of US money, published in 1963. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Milton Friedman and Anna J. Schwartz, Princeton University Press for the National Bureau of Economic Research - 日期 1963
[S19] Edmund S. Phelps, Economica 34(135)
Phelps's analysis of Phillips curves that depend on expected inflation, published in August 1967. Phelps analyses Phillips curves that depend on expected inflation. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Edmund S. Phelps, Economica 34(135) - 日期 1967
[S20] Milton Friedman (editor), University of Chicago Press
Essays on the quantity theory of money, edited by Friedman.
学术与研究资料 - Milton Friedman (editor), University of Chicago Press - 日期 1956
[S21] Brian Snowdon and Howard R. Vane, Edward Elgar
A survey of the origins, development and current state of modern macroeconomics.
学术与研究资料 - Brian Snowdon and Howard R. Vane, Edward Elgar - 日期 2005
[S22] Marvin Goodfriend and Robert G. King, Journal of Monetary Economics 52(5)
Argues that the real effects of the Volcker disinflation were mainly due to imperfect credibility, visible in volatile and stubborn long-term interest rates.
学术与研究资料 - Marvin Goodfriend and Robert G. King, Journal of Monetary Economics 52(5) - 日期 2005
[S23] Edmund S. Phelps
Phelps models money-wage dynamics with labor-market equilibrium. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Edmund S. Phelps - 日期 1968
[S24] Richard Clarida, Jordi Galí and Mark Gertler, Journal of Economic Literature 37(4)
The survey that set out the policy problem in the baseline New Keynesian model, with and without commitment. In the baseline model, the coefficient on the output gap falls as prices get stickier, and a credible commitment to fight inflation improves the current output-inflation trade-off. Accessed 2026-11-14. The survey sets out optimal policy with and without commitment: cost-push inflation creates a short-run trade-off, and the optimal rule under commitment depends on the history of shocks. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Richard Clarida, Jordi Galí and Mark Gertler, Journal of Economic Literature 37(4) - 日期 1999
[S25] Michael Woodford, Princeton University Press
Derives interest-rate policy and an inflation-targeting regime from an explicit analysis of household welfare. Woodford designs an optimal inflation-targeting regime grounded in an explicit welfare analysis and argues for rule-based policy. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Michael Woodford, Princeton University Press - 日期 2003
[S26] Jordi Galí, second edition, Princeton University Press
The standard graduate introduction to the New Keynesian model, including cost-push shocks and optimal policy. The New Keynesian framework is a backbone of the medium-scale models under development at major central banks. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Jordi Galí, second edition, Princeton University Press - 日期 2015
[S27] Jordi Galí and Mark Gertler, Journal of Monetary Economics 44(2)
Estimates a Phillips curve that allows backward-looking firms: marginal cost drives inflation, and backward-looking price setting is statistically significant but not quantitatively important.
学术与研究资料 - Jordi Galí and Mark Gertler, Journal of Monetary Economics 44(2) - 日期 1999
[S28] Emi Nakamura and Jón Steinsson, Quarterly Journal of Economics 123(4)
US micro price data: excluding sales, the median consumer price changes in roughly 9 to 12 percent of months.
学术与研究资料 - Emi Nakamura and Jón Steinsson, Quarterly Journal of Economics 123(4) - 日期 2008
[S29] Mark Gertler and Peter Karadi, American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics 7(1)
Identifies policy shocks from high-frequency surprises around announcements: modest moves in short rates produce large moves in credit costs, with the usual responses of output and inflation.
学术与研究资料 - Mark Gertler and Peter Karadi, American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics 7(1) - 日期 2015
[S30] Guillermo A. Calvo
In Calvo's formulation each firm has a fixed probability each period of being able to adjust its price, independent of the time since its last change. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Guillermo A. Calvo - 日期 1983
[S31] John B. Taylor
Staggered contracts generate persistence that outlasts the longest contract. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - John B. Taylor - 日期 1980
[S32] Jonathon Hazell, Juan Herreño, Emi Nakamura and Jón Steinsson
The slope of the Phillips curve is small and was small in the early 1980s; the stability of inflation from 1990 to 2020 is mostly due to anchored long-run expectations. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Jonathon Hazell, Juan Herreño, Emi Nakamura and Jón Steinsson - 日期 2022
[S33] Olivier Blanchard and Jordi Galí
In the standard New Keynesian model, stabilizing inflation is equivalent to stabilizing the welfare-relevant output gap, the divine coincidence, which real wage rigidities remove. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Olivier Blanchard and Jordi Galí - 日期 2007
[S34] Greg Kaplan, Benjamin Moll and Giovanni L. Violante, American Economic Review 108(3)
In a heterogeneous-agent New Keynesian model, the indirect effects of a rate cut through labor demand far outweigh direct intertemporal substitution. Indirect effects of a rate cut far outweigh direct intertemporal substitution; the fiscal reaction is a key determinant of the overall response. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Greg Kaplan, Benjamin Moll and Giovanni L. Violante, American Economic Review 108(3) - 日期 2018
[S35] Adrien Auclert, American Economic Review 109(6)
Three redistribution channels of monetary policy (earnings heterogeneity, the Fisher channel and interest-rate exposure), measured with Italian and US data. Three redistribution channels of monetary policy are likely to amplify its effect on spending. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Adrien Auclert, American Economic Review 109(6) - 日期 2019
[S36] Greg Kaplan and Giovanni L. Violante, Journal of Economic Perspectives 32(3)
A survey of heterogeneous-agent New Keynesian models: how close they are to the representative-agent model depends on the shock being studied. The similarity between representative-agent and HANK models depends crucially on the shock being analyzed. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Greg Kaplan and Giovanni L. Violante, Journal of Economic Perspectives 32(3) - 日期 2018
[S37] S. R. Aiyagari, Quarterly Journal of Economics 109(3)
The growth model with precautionary saving and liquidity constraints, and what they do to aggregate saving and to wealth inequality. Aiyagari adds precautionary saving and liquidity constraints to the growth model and studies aggregate saving and wealth inequality. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - S. R. Aiyagari, Quarterly Journal of Economics 109(3) - 日期 1994
[S38] David S. Johnson, Jonathan A. Parker and Nicholas S. Souleles, American Economic Review 96(5)
Uses the randomized timing of the 2001 rebates: households spent 20 to 40 percent on nondurables within three months, more where liquid wealth or income was low. Households spent 20 to 40 percent of the 2001 rebates on nondurables within three months, more where liquid wealth or income was low. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - David S. Johnson, Jonathan A. Parker and Nicholas S. Souleles, American Economic Review 96(5) - 日期 2006
[S39] Mark Huggett
Huggett studies the risk-free interest rate in an economy whose households cannot insure their income risk. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Mark Huggett - 日期 1993
[S40] Per Krusell and Anthony A. Smith Jr.
In the stationary stochastic equilibrium, the aggregates can be described almost perfectly by the mean of the wealth distribution; matching wealth data needs some heterogeneity in thrift. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Per Krusell and Anthony A. Smith Jr. - 日期 1998
[S41] Greg Kaplan and Giovanni L. Violante
Many households are wealthy hand-to-mouth, holding little liquid wealth despite sizeable illiquid assets, and so spend a large share of transitory income. Accessed 2026-11-14.
学术与研究资料 - Greg Kaplan and Giovanni L. Violante - 日期 2014