Sources universitaires et de recherche
Sims (1980) -- introduced the VAR framework and the recursive identification approach
Econometrica · 1980
Blanchard and Quah (1989) -- long-run identification using permanent/transitory decomposition
Uhlig (2005) -- sign-restriction identification for monetary policy shocks
Journal of Monetary Economics · 2005
Rubio-Ramirez, Waggoner, and Zha (2010) -- algorithm for drawing from the identified set under sign restrictions
Review of Economic Studies · 2010
Stock and Watson (2012) -- external instruments for SVAR identification (disentangling supply and demand)
Brookings Papers on Economic Activity · 2012
Mertens and Ravn (2013) -- proxy SVAR methodology and fiscal policy application
American Economic Review · 2013
Gertler and Karadi (2015) -- proxy SVAR for monetary policy using high-frequency surprises
American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics · 2015
Kilian (2009) -- recursive SVAR for oil market shocks
American Economic Review · 2009
An Empirical Characterization of the Dynamic Effects of Changes in Government Spending and Taxes
Blanchard and Perotti on institutional timing restrictions.
Quarterly Journal of Economics · 2002
Fondements de recherche
Éléments probants et données
The identifying restriction is the research design. Report the restriction, horizon, data vintage, and sensitivity checks.
Calibrage ou mesure
Ordering, sign restrictions, instruments, and shock normalization determine the structural impulse response.
Limites
- Different admissible restrictions can tell different stories.
- Weak instruments damage proxy SVARs.
- Historical decompositions inherit identification risk.
Conseils d’utilisation
Quand le modèle suffit
Identified impulse responses to a small number of structural shocks when the identification scheme, whether recursive ordering, sign restrictions, long-run restrictions (Blanchard-Quah 1989 AER), or an external instrument, is credible and can be defended. The standard tool for estimating the effect of a monetary-policy shock, a government-spending shock, or an oil-supply disruption when theory restricts the impact or frequency-domain behavior of the shock.
Quand il reste une esquisse
Do not use when the identifying restriction is itself the contested question. If the debate is whether central banks reacted to output or output reacted to central banks, a recursive SVAR that resolves this by assumption is not a structural test; it is a labeling exercise. Sign-restricted SVARs can also be under-identified, with a wide posterior set of admissible impulse responses.
Quand changer de modèle
Switch to an external-instrument SVAR (Mertens-Ravn 2013 AER; Stock-Watson 2018 JEEA proxy-SVAR) when a narrative or high-frequency surprise measure provides a stronger instrument than within-sample restrictions. Switch to an estimated DSGE (dsge:nk) when the structural interpretation of each shock needs to be pinned to a specific friction rather than a timing or sign assumption.
Signal de réfutation
Impulse responses that flip sign or change magnitude substantially across plausible but distinct identification schemes on the same dataset indicate the result is not robust to identification uncertainty. A monetary shock that appears contractionary under recursive ordering but expansionary under sign restrictions signals that the data do not sharply identify the shock, regardless of which label is assigned.