Cookies sur Macro by Mark.Nous utilisons des cookies essentiels pour la connexion, la langue et la sécurité. Avec votre accord, nous ajoutons des cookies optionnels de préférences, d’analyse et de mesure publicitaire avec le pixel Meta (Facebook). Lisez notre politique relative aux cookies.
Identified vector autoregression that turns reduced-form residuals into economically named structural shocks.
Follow the same equations and assumptions one section at a time or in a continuous reading.
Hover or focus a symbol defined in this model to find its exact matches. Select it to keep the highlight; Escape clears the selection.
Start from the reduced-form :
The reduced-form residuals are composites of the underlying structural shocks . Define the structural model as , where is invertible and (diagonal, typically ). Pre-multiplying by recovers the reduced form with .
The covariance restriction is:
This system of equations has unique entries on the left (since is symmetric) and unknowns in on the right. The gap is restrictions. For a bivariate system, that's 1 restriction. For a 4-variable system, 6. These must come from outside the data.
Without additional restrictions, the structural parameters are not identified. Any orthogonal matrix produces an observationally equivalent decomposition: if satisfies the covariance equation, so does for any . The set of all such rotations forms the orthogonal group , which has dimension - exactly the identification deficit.
The reduced-form VAR: observable variables, estimated coefficients, composite residuals.
The structural mapping. Each column of is the instantaneous effect of one structural shock on all variables.
equations, unknowns. The gap of is the identification problem.
Any orthogonal rotation of a valid decomposition is also valid. This is why identification requires restrictions beyond the covariance matrix.
Why Cholesky became the default
The lower-triangular Cholesky factor of a positive-definite matrix is unique. Setting imposes zero restrictions (a zero upper triangle), which is exactly the deficit. This is why Sims (1980) used recursive ordering - it's the simplest way to fill the gap. But 'simplest' is not 'most credible.'
Set identification vs. point identification
Sign restrictions typically do not pin down a unique . They define an identified set - all rotations satisfying the sign constraints. The IRF is then an interval, not a point. Researchers report the pointwise median and the 16th/84th percentile bounds of the identified set, but these are not confidence intervals in the frequentist sense. They reflect identification uncertainty, not sampling uncertainty.
In a linear state-space representation, B maps the innovation into the contemporaneous state. A delayed variable has a zero row in B and moves only after A propagates the shock. A jump is therefore a timing restriction, not a charting artifact.
A nonzero point at h=0 means the shock changes the plotted variable on impact. It is not the end of a smooth pre-shock segment.
Do not smooth through h=0 when the model says the shock enters contemporaneously.
Stable eigenvalues shrink repeated applications of A. If a variable is reached through another state first, the response rises before the stable decay dominates, producing a hump-shaped path.
Post-impact movement follows the model recursion. A hump means delayed propagation, not interpolation by the chart.
Do not treat a hump as evidence of a linear ramp unless the model includes that ramp.
The shock is dated at horizon zero. A response at h=0 is an impact effect, not the end of a hidden ramp.
A state can move on impact only through the relevant row of B; otherwise it moves after A propagates the shock.
The plotted variable can jump directly through D or indirectly through the state vector.