A map of the heterodox branches and where they disagree
Heterodox economics is not one school. Tony Lawson treats the label as an umbrella for separate traditions that have come together, and argues that what sets them apart from the mainstream is a view of how the economy is constituted, not a commitment to a particular theory, policy or technique [1]. Each branch on this site moves a different variable into the center of the analysis.
Post-Keynesians start from money and uncertainty: the effective demand of Keynes's General Theory (1936) [2] and Hyman Minsky's account of how long booms move finance from hedge to speculative and Ponzi positions [3]. Marxians start from accumulation and profit, following Capital (1867) [4]. Institutionalists start from rules and organizations, from Thorstein Veblen's Theory of Business Enterprise (1904) onward [5]. Feminist economists start from care and social provisioning, treating unpaid caring labor as a fundamental economic activity [6]. Ecological economists start from physical limits, with Kenneth Boulding's essay on the coming spaceship earth (1966) as an early landmark [7]. Modern Monetary Theory starts from how a currency-issuing state finances itself, drawing on Georg Friedrich Knapp's state theory of money, first published in German in 1905 [8].
The branches often disagree with each other as sharply as with the mainstream. Thomas Palley argues that MMT restates established Keynesian monetary economics while understating the problems posed by the Phillips curve, financial stability and the open economy [9]. Ecological economists question whether growth, which demand-led policy usually counts on to raise employment, can continue at all; Tim Jackson asks how employment and stability could be kept in an economy that no longer grows [10]. Marxian crisis theory locates instability in accumulation, the falling rate of profit and the problem of realizing profits in sales [11], where Post-Keynesians locate it in finance and expectations.
Some of these concerns have reached the debate over official statistics. The Stiglitz-Sen-Fitoussi commission recommended broadening income measures to non-market activities and assessing sustainability with a dashboard of indicators [12], two recommendations that line up with the feminist and ecological branches. Distributional national accounts show why averages can mislead: average pretax income per US adult rose 60 percent from 1980 to 2014, while the bottom half's stagnated at about $16,000 a year [13].
What the branches share is a refusal to let a model leave out the variable they think does the work. Mainstream economics has absorbed some of their points, from financial frictions to differences between households, which is why this guide asks each branch to name its mechanism and the evidence that would count against it.