Skip to main content

Cookies on Macro by Mark.We use essential cookies for sign-in, locale, and security. With your permission, we also use optional cookies for preferences, for analytics, and for advertising measurement with the Meta (Facebook) Pixel. Read our cookie policy.

Macro by MarkMacro by Mark
  • Home
Loading…
Loading…
← Models
MacroConceptsPolicyModels

Semi-structural core Model

A core block of estimated macro equations - output, inflation, labor, policy - wired together without full DSGE micro-foundations.

OverviewGraphMathReferences

How do you impose structural economic relationships on a forecasting model without committing to a fully micro-founded DSGE specification?

Background

Fully atheoretical models like VARs treat every variable symmetrically and let the data decide everything. Fully structural models like DSGE impose general equilibrium from first principles. Central banks found both extremes unsatisfying. Reduced-form VARs forecast well at short horizons, and identified (structural) VARs can estimate the effects of policy shocks, but neither can say what happens under a systematically different policy rule without assuming the estimated relationships stay put (the Lucas critique). DSGE models can answer counterfactuals but forecast poorly at horizons that matter for monetary-policy decisions. The semi-structural approach splits the difference: impose a small number of structural equations grounded in economic theory (IS curve, Phillips curve, policy rule, exchange rate arbitrage), but estimate their coefficients from the data rather than deriving them from household optimization. The Bank of Canada's Quarterly Projection Model (QPM, 1994) and the Reserve Bank of New Zealand's FPS were early examples. The IMF's FPAS framework (Berg, Karam, and Laxton 2006) generalized the approach for member-country surveillance.

A semi-structural core typically contains four to six behavioral equations. An IS-type equation links the output gap to the real interest rate gap, the real exchange rate gap, and foreign demand. A Phillips-curve equation links inflation to the output gap, expected inflation, and import prices. A monetary-policy reaction function (Taylor-type rule) links the nominal interest rate to the inflation gap and the output gap. An uncovered interest parity condition links the exchange rate to the interest differential. Trend-cycle decomposition equations separate each observed variable into a stochastic trend (potential output, equilibrium real rate, trend inflation) and a cyclical gap. The gaps, not the levels, drive the behavioral equations.

What distinguishes the semi-structural core from reduced-form VARs is the a priori identification of structural shocks. What distinguishes it from DSGE is the absence of explicit intertemporal optimization or cross-equation restrictions derived from micro foundations. Parameters are estimated or calibrated equation by equation. Expectations can be model-consistent (forward-looking, iterated from the model's own solution) or adaptive (backward-looking weighted averages). Most implementations use a mix: forward-looking expectations in the Phillips curve and policy rule, backward-looking dynamics in the IS curve.

The Bank of Canada's LENS, the IMF's Global Projection Model (GPM), and the Reserve Bank of India's QPM all use semi-structural cores. (The Czech National Bank's g3/g3+, by contrast, is a micro-founded DSGE that replaced its semi-structural QPM in 2008.) These models are the workhorse for medium-term forecasting (4-8 quarter horizon) and scenario analysis at inflation-targeting central banks. They are updated quarterly with judgment overlays - staff can adjust trends, impose conditioning paths for commodity prices or fiscal policy, and override model-implied gaps when the filter produces implausible estimates.

Connections to explore

Math ↗The structure and its conditions, step by step.References ↗Academic sources and guidance for using the model.

How the Parts Fit Together

y~t\tilde{y}_ty~​t​

Output gap

Deviation of log real GDP from potential output. Drives Phillips curve inflation and responds to monetary-policy-induced changes in the real interest rate gap.

Inputs consist of a small set of observed macroeconomic variables: real GDP (or a proxy), CPI inflation, the policy interest rate, the nominal exchange rate, and sometimes the terms of trade or fiscal balance. Each observed variable is decomposed into a trend and a gap. The trend components (potential output, equilibrium real interest rate, trend inflation) follow random walks or local linear trends with estimated drift. The gap components (output gap, real interest rate gap, real exchange rate gap) are the deviations of observed variables from their trends. This decomposition is typically performed with a multivariate Kalman filter or a Hodrick-Prescott-style penalty embedded in the estimation.

The behavioral core consists of IS curve, Phillips curve, monetary policy rule, and UIP condition, all written in gap form. The IS curve: y~t=βlagy~t−1+βleadEt[y~t+1]−βrr~t−βzz~t+εtIS\tilde{y}_t = \beta_{\text{lag}} \tilde{y}_{t-1} + \beta_{\text{lead}} E_t[\tilde{y}_{t+1}] - \beta_r \tilde{r}_t - \beta_z \tilde{z}_t + \varepsilon_t^{\text{IS}}y~​t​=βlag​y~​t−1​+βlead​Et​[y~​t+1​]−βr​r~t​−βz​z~t​+εtIS​. The Phillips curve: πt=αleadEt[πt+1]+(1−αlead)πt−1+αyy~t−αzΔzt+εtπ\pi_t = \alpha_{\text{lead}} E_t[\pi_{t+1}] + (1 - \alpha_{\text{lead}}) \pi_{t-1} + \alpha_y \tilde{y}_t - \alpha_z \Delta z_t + \varepsilon_t^{\pi}πt​=αlead​Et​[πt+1​]+(1−αlead​)πt−1​+αy​y~​t​−αz​Δzt​+εtπ​. The policy rule: it=γlagit−1+(1−γlag)[rt∗+π∗+γπ(πt4−π∗)+γyy~t]+εtMPi_t = \gamma_{\text{lag}} i_{t-1} + (1 - \gamma_{\text{lag}}) [r^*_t + \pi^* + \gamma_{\pi} (\pi^4_t - \pi^*) + \gamma_y \tilde{y}_t] + \varepsilon_t^{\text{MP}}it​=γlag​it−1​+(1−γlag​)[rt∗​+π∗+γπ​(πt4​−π∗)+γy​y~​t​]+εtMP​. The UIP: z~t=δEt[z~t+1]+(r~t−r~tforeign)/4+εtUIP\tilde{z}_t = \delta E_t[\tilde{z}_{t+1}] + (\tilde{r}_t - \tilde{r}_t^{\text{foreign}}) / 4 + \varepsilon_t^{\text{UIP}}z~t​=δEt​[z~t+1​]+(r~t​−r~tforeign​)/4+εtUIP​.

Estimation and calibration vary by institution. Some parameters (expectations weights, policy rule coefficients) are calibrated from institutional priors or micro evidence. Others (persistence, shock variances) are estimated by maximum likelihood, Bayesian methods, or a combination of both. The Kalman filter provides the likelihood function and simultaneously filters the unobserved trends and gaps. The model is solved as a linear rational expectations system when forward-looking expectations are present, typically using the method of Blanchard-Kahn (1980) or Anderson-Moore (AIM) algorithm.

Assumptions

Testable

Gap linearity

All behavioral relationships are linear in the gaps. Output gap, inflation gap, and interest rate gap interact proportionally with no threshold effects or asymmetries.

If violated:Nonlinear Phillips curves (convex at low unemployment) or asymmetric IS responses (ZLB) are missed. The model underestimates inflation at tight labor markets and cannot capture liquidity traps.

Maintained

Trend-cycle separability

Each observed variable decomposes cleanly into a slowly moving trend and a stationary gap: Xt=Xˉt+X~tX_t = \bar{X}_t + \tilde{X}_tXt​=Xˉt​+X~t​. The trend is independent of the gap conditional on the model's state.

If violated:Hysteresis (recessions permanently lowering potential) violates separability. Filtered output gaps will be biased toward zero at the end of deep recessions, producing systematically wrong policy prescriptions.

Maintained

Rational or quasi-rational expectations

Agents form expectations of future inflation and output gaps consistent with the model's own law of motion (model-consistent expectations) or as a weighted average of forward-looking and backward-looking components.

If violated:If expectations are heterogeneous or formed through non-model-consistent heuristics (e.g., sticky information), the model misprices the speed of adjustment to shocks and overestimates the impact of forward guidance.

Testable

Structural stability

Coefficients in the IS curve, Phillips curve, and policy rule are constant over the estimation window. The monetary policy regime does not change.

If violated:Regime shifts (inflation targeting adoption, ZLB episodes, pandemic responses) make pre-break estimates unreliable for post-break forecasting. Parameters like the Phillips curve slope may shift after anchoring.

Testable

Small-open-economy structure (for open-economy variants)

The domestic economy is too small to affect foreign variables. Foreign output gap, foreign interest rate, and foreign inflation are exogenous.

If violated:For large economies (US, China, Eurozone) or during global synchronized shocks, the small-open-economy assumption produces inconsistent cross-country forecasts. Spillbacks are ignored.

Testable

Shock orthogonality

Structural disturbances εtIS\varepsilon_t^{\text{IS}}εtIS​, εtπ\varepsilon_t^{\pi}εtπ​, εtMP\varepsilon_t^{\text{MP}}εtMP​ and εtUIP\varepsilon_t^{\text{UIP}}εtUIP​ are mutually uncorrelated at all leads and lags.

If violated:Correlated shocks (stagflation: simultaneous demand collapse and cost-push) produce biased impulse responses. The model attributes joint movements to whichever equation fits best, not to a common cause.

Applications

The IMF uses the FPAS semi-structural framework for Article IV surveillance missions in over 40 member countries. The model provides a consistent language for output-gap estimation, inflation forecasting, and policy-rate path advice. The Czech National Bank ran a semi-structural QPM as its forecasting core until 2008, when the micro-founded g3 DSGE (now g3+) replaced it - the canonical example of a central bank graduating from a semi-structural core to DSGE. The Reserve Bank of India adopted a semi-structural model (QPM) for inflation targeting after 2016.

Beyond point forecasts, semi-structural models excel at scenario and risk analysis. Staff impose alternative paths for oil prices, fiscal spending, or exchange rates, re-solve the model, and present fan charts to policymakers. The Bank of Canada's LENS and the IMF's GPM pair semi-structural cores with satellite modules for sectoral detail. (The Bank of England's COMPASS and Norges Bank's NEMO, by contrast, are structural New Keynesian DSGE models, not semi-structural cores.) The approach has been adapted for climate scenario analysis by layering carbon-price shocks through the Phillips curve and potential-output channels.

Calibration-heavy variants are used for teaching and training at the IMF Institute, the Joint Vienna Institute, and central bank staff colleges. The transparency of the IS-Phillips-Taylor structure makes the model a pedagogical entry point before students encounter DSGE. This is a strength: the model's simplicity is the reason it survived alongside DSGE, not despite it.

Do not use a semi-structural core when the question involves sectoral reallocation (the model has one aggregate output gap), financial stability (no credit or asset-price channels unless bolted on), distributional effects (representative agent by construction), or structural transformation (the Kalman filter's random-walk trends cannot handle discrete regime changes in potential growth).

Extensions and open questions

Variants

  • QPM (Bank of Canada, 1994): the original semi-structural quarterly projection model with model-consistent expectations and endogenous credibility
  • FPAS-lite (IMF): reduced 4-equation core for small developing economies with limited data availability
  • GPM (Global Projection Model): multi-country extension with trade and financial linkages between US, Euro area, Japan, and emerging markets
  • LENS (Bank of Canada): large semi-structural projection model used alongside the DSGE ToTEM for forecasting and risk analysis
  • QPM (Reserve Bank of India): semi-structural quarterly projection model adopted for flexible inflation targeting after 2016

Open questions

  • How should semi-structural models handle the effective lower bound on interest rates? Adding a ZLB constraint makes the model nonlinear and breaks standard solution methods.
  • Can machine-learning-estimated Phillips curves (nonparametric or neural-network-based) replace the linear specification without losing interpretability for policy communication?
  • How do you calibrate expectations formation weights (forward vs. backward) when survey data on expectations is limited or unreliable?

Keep going

Read next

Continue with a related concept, model, or example.

Theory model

IS-LM Model

a well-connected theoretical model two steps from here

New angle: theoretical model →
Macro by Mark
Help
Privacy PolicyTerms of UseEthics and Compliance

© 2026 Mark Jayson Nation LLC