Households have an effectively infinite planning horizon (or operative intergenerational bequest motive).
Finite lifetimes break equivalence unless dynastically linked agents internalize their descendants' tax burdens.
Macro by Mark の Cookie.ログイン、言語、安全性のために必須 Cookie を使用します。許可いただいた場合は、設定の保存、分析、Meta(Facebook)ピクセルによる広告計測のために任意の Cookie も使用します。詳しくはCookie ポリシーをご覧ください。
The proposition that a debt-financed tax cut has no effect on consumption because rational, forward-looking agents save the windfall to pay future tax liabilities.
Does it matter whether government spending is financed by taxes today or by borrowing (taxes tomorrow)?
Ricardian equivalence asks whether the timing of taxes matters when government spending is unchanged. If households internalize future tax liabilities, a debt-financed tax cut raises private saving rather than consumption.
Barro's 1974 formulation made the proposition central to modern fiscal theory. It is a benchmark, not a universal prediction.
The model is valuable because its failure conditions are policy-relevant: finite horizons, liquidity constraints, uncertain future taxes, distortionary taxation, and incomplete bequest motives.
Household consumption spending.
The corresponding element is highlighted on the graph.
Full Ricardian offset: the tax cut has zero effect on consumption.
The deficit grows at r to a repayment of 16.29 in 10 periods; discounted back at the same r its present value equals today's cut exactly. That invariance is the equivalence theorem.
The gap between Keynesian and Ricardian lines measures the degree of forward-looking behavior.
The government budget constraint says borrowing today implies taxes tomorrow, unless spending changes or debt is inflated away.
A fully Ricardian household treats the tax cut as offset by the present value of future taxes. Private wealth does not rise, so consumption does not rise.
A partial Ricardian setting mixes households that save the tax cut with households that spend from current disposable income.
Finite lifetimes break equivalence unless dynastically linked agents internalize their descendants' tax burdens.
Liquidity constraints or borrowing premia prevent households from fully smoothing the tax shift.
If taxes are distortionary, the timing of taxation affects allocations even for Ricardian households.
Fiscal-multiplier debates use the benchmark to separate pure timing effects from changes in government purchases or transfers to constrained households.
Stimulus checks have larger demand effects when they reach households with high marginal propensities to consume and limited liquidity. U.S. households spent 20 to 40 percent of their 2001 tax rebates on nondurable goods in the three months the rebates arrived (Johnson, Parker and Souleles 2006), where a strictly Ricardian household would spend none. Classic surveys of the wider evidence are Bernheim (1987) and Seater (1993).
Debt-financed tax cuts can still matter through distribution, tax distortions, uncertainty, default risk, and political-economy channels outside the clean theorem.
A tax cut is fully debt-financed and government purchases do not change. What does a Ricardian household do with the windfall?
Which assumption fails when young households cannot borrow against future income?
Why does a change in government purchases differ from a change in tax timing?
How would distortionary future taxes weaken the equivalence result?