Zum Hauptinhalt springen

Cookies bei Macro by Mark.Wir verwenden notwendige Cookies für Anmeldung, Sprache und Sicherheit. Mit Ihrer Einwilligung verwenden wir außerdem optionale Cookies für Präferenzen, für Analysen und für Werbemessung mit dem Meta-(Facebook-)Pixel. Lesen Sie unsere Cookie-Richtlinie.

Macro by MarkMacro by Mark
  • Start
Wird geladen …
Wird geladen …
← Modelle
MacroKonzepteWirtschaftspolitikModelle

Structural VAR (SVAR) Model

Identified vector autoregression that turns reduced-form residuals into economically named structural shocks.

ÜberblickDiagrammMathematikQuellen

Understand the mathematics

Follow the same equations and assumptions one section at a time or in a continuous reading.

Hover or focus a symbol defined in this model to find its exact matches. Select it to keep the highlight; Escape clears the selection.

The Identification Problem

Start from the reduced-form VAR(p)\text{VAR}(p)VAR(p):

The reduced-form residuals utu_tut​ are composites of the underlying structural shocks εt\varepsilon_tεt​. Define the structural model as B0yt=Γ0+Γ1yt−1+⋯+Γpyt−p+εtB_0 y_t = \Gamma_0 + \Gamma_1 y_{t-1} + \cdots + \Gamma_p y_{t-p} + \varepsilon_tB0​yt​=Γ0​+Γ1​yt−1​+⋯+Γp​yt−p​+εt​, where B0B_0B0​ is invertible and E[εtεt′]=DE[\varepsilon_t \varepsilon_t'] = DE[εt​εt​′]=D (diagonal, typically InI_nIn​). Pre-multiplying by B0−1B_0^{-1}B0−1​ recovers the reduced form with ut=B0−1εtu_t = B_0^{-1} \varepsilon_tut​=B0−1​εt​.

The covariance restriction is:

This system of equations has n(n+1)/2n(n+1)/2n(n+1)/2 unique entries on the left (since Σu\Sigma_uΣu​ is symmetric) and n2n^2n2 unknowns in B0−1B_0^{-1}B0−1​ on the right. The gap is n2−n(n+1)/2=n(n−1)/2n^2 - n(n+1)/2 = n(n-1)/2n2−n(n+1)/2=n(n−1)/2 restrictions. For a bivariate system, that's 1 restriction. For a 4-variable system, 6. These must come from outside the data.

Without additional restrictions, the structural parameters are not identified. Any orthogonal matrix QQQ produces an observationally equivalent decomposition: if B0−1B_0^{-1}B0−1​ satisfies the covariance equation, so does B~0−1=B0−1Q\tilde{B}_0^{-1} = B_0^{-1} QB~0−1​=B0−1​Q for any Q′Q=InQ'Q = I_nQ′Q=In​. The set of all such rotations forms the orthogonal group O(n)O(n)O(n), which has dimension n(n−1)/2n(n-1)/2n(n−1)/2 - exactly the identification deficit.

yt=c+A1yt−1+⋯+Apyt−p+ut,E[utut′]=Σuy_t = c + A_1 y_{t-1} + \cdots + A_p y_{t-p} + u_t, \quad E[u_t u_t'] = \Sigma_uyt​=c+A1​yt−1​+⋯+Ap​yt−p​+ut​,E[ut​ut′​]=Σu​
Σu\Sigma_uΣu​

The reduced-form VAR: observable variables, estimated coefficients, composite residuals.

ut=B0−1εt,E[εtεt′]=Inu_t = B_0^{-1} \varepsilon_t, \quad E[\varepsilon_t \varepsilon_t'] = I_nut​=B0−1​εt​,E[εt​εt​′]=In​
B0−1B_0^{-1}B0−1​εt\varepsilon_tεt​

The structural mapping. Each column of B0−1B_0^{-1}B0−1​ is the instantaneous effect of one structural shock on all variables.

Σu=B0−1(B0−1)′\Sigma_u = B_0^{-1} (B_0^{-1})'Σu​=B0−1​(B0−1​)′
Σu\Sigma_uΣu​B0−1B_0^{-1}B0−1​

n(n+1)/2n(n+1)/2n(n+1)/2 equations, n2n^2n2 unknowns. The gap of n(n−1)/2n(n-1)/2n(n−1)/2 is the identification problem.

B~0−1=B0−1Q,Q′Q=In  ⟹  B~0−1(B~0−1)′=B0−1QQ′(B0−1)′=Σu\tilde{B}_0^{-1} = B_0^{-1} Q, \quad Q'Q = I_n \implies \tilde{B}_0^{-1} (\tilde{B}_0^{-1})' = B_0^{-1} Q Q' (B_0^{-1})' = \Sigma_uB~0−1​=B0−1​Q,Q′Q=In​⟹B~0−1​(B~0−1​)′=B0−1​QQ′(B0−1​)′=Σu​
B0−1B_0^{-1}B0−1​QQQΣu\Sigma_uΣu​

Any orthogonal rotation of a valid decomposition is also valid. This is why identification requires restrictions beyond the covariance matrix.

Derive the reduced form from the structural model

Pre-multiply the structural model by B0−1B_0^{-1}B0−1​ to isolate yty_tyt​. The reduced-form coefficients are Aj=B0−1ΓjA_j = B_0^{-1} \Gamma_jAj​=B0−1​Γj​.
B0yt=Γ0+∑j=1pΓjyt−j+εt  ⟹  yt=B0−1Γ0+∑j=1pB0−1Γjyt−j+B0−1εtB_0 y_t = \Gamma_0 + \sum_{j=1}^p \Gamma_j y_{t-j} + \varepsilon_t \implies y_t = B_0^{-1} \Gamma_0 + \sum_{j=1}^p B_0^{-1} \Gamma_j y_{t-j} + B_0^{-1} \varepsilon_tB0​yt​=Γ0​+j=1∑p​Γj​yt−j​+εt​⟹yt​=B0−1​Γ0​+j=1∑p​B0−1​Γj​yt−j​+B0−1​εt​
εt\varepsilon_tεt​B0−1B_0^{-1}B0−1​

Compute the covariance of reduced-form residuals

Orthogonality and unit variance of structural shocks simplify the expectation.
Σu=E[utut′]=E[B0−1εtεt′(B0−1)′]=B0−1In(B0−1)′=B0−1(B0−1)′\Sigma_u = E[u_t u_t'] = E[B_0^{-1} \varepsilon_t \varepsilon_t' (B_0^{-1})'] = B_0^{-1} I_n (B_0^{-1})' = B_0^{-1} (B_0^{-1})'Σu​=E[ut​ut′​]=E[B0−1​εt​εt​′(B0−1​)′]=B0−1​In​(B0−1​)′=B0−1​(B0−1​)′
Σu\Sigma_uΣu​B0−1B_0^{-1}B0−1​εt\varepsilon_tεt​

Count equations vs. unknowns

Σu\Sigma_uΣu​ is symmetric, so only n(n+1)/2n(n+1)/2n(n+1)/2 of its entries are distinct. B0−1B_0^{-1}B0−1​ has n2n^2n2 free entries.
Equations: n(n+1)2,Unknowns: n2,Deficit: n(n−1)2\text{Equations: } \frac{n(n+1)}{2}, \quad \text{Unknowns: } n^2, \quad \text{Deficit: } \frac{n(n-1)}{2}Equations: 2n(n+1)​,Unknowns: n2,Deficit: 2n(n−1)​

Show observational equivalence under rotation

Orthogonality of Q guarantees the rotated decomposition produces the same reduced-form covariance.
Σ~u=(B0−1Q)(B0−1Q)′=B0−1QQ′⏟=In(B0−1)′=Σu\tilde{\Sigma}_u = (B_0^{-1} Q)(B_0^{-1} Q)' = B_0^{-1} \underbrace{Q Q'}_{= I_n} (B_0^{-1})' = \Sigma_uΣ~u​=(B0−1​Q)(B0−1​Q)′=B0−1​=In​QQ′​​(B0−1​)′=Σu​
B0−1B_0^{-1}B0−1​QQQΣu\Sigma_uΣu​

Dimension of the orthogonal group matches the deficit

The manifold of orthogonal matrices has exactly the same dimension as the identification deficit. This is not a coincidence - it is the geometric content of the identification problem.
dim⁡O(n)=n(n−1)2\dim O(n) = \frac{n(n-1)}{2}dimO(n)=2n(n−1)​

State the identification requirement

These restrictions must come from economic theory, institutional timing, long-run neutrality, external instruments, or inequality constraints.
Point identification requires n(n−1)2 additional restrictions on B0−1\text{Point identification requires } \frac{n(n-1)}{2} \text{ additional restrictions on } B_0^{-1}Point identification requires 2n(n−1)​ additional restrictions on B0−1​
B0−1B_0^{-1}B0−1​

Why Cholesky became the default

The lower-triangular Cholesky factor of a positive-definite matrix is unique. Setting B0−1=chol⁡(Σu)B_0^{-1} = \operatorname{chol}(\Sigma_u)B0−1​=chol(Σu​) imposes n(n−1)/2n(n-1)/2n(n−1)/2 zero restrictions (a zero upper triangle), which is exactly the deficit. This is why Sims (1980) used recursive ordering - it's the simplest way to fill the gap. But 'simplest' is not 'most credible.'

Set identification vs. point identification

Sign restrictions typically do not pin down a unique B0−1B_0^{-1}B0−1​. They define an identified set - all rotations QQQ satisfying the sign constraints. The IRF is then an interval, not a point. Researchers report the pointwise median and the 16th/84th percentile bounds of the identified set, but these are not confidence intervals in the frequentist sense. They reflect identification uncertainty, not sampling uncertainty.

Transition checks

Impact jump
x0=Bε0,xh=AhBε0(h=1,2,…)x_0=B\varepsilon_0,\qquad x_h=A^hB\varepsilon_0\quad(h=1,2,\ldots)x0​=Bε0​,xh​=AhBε0​(h=1,2,…)

In a linear state-space representation, B maps the innovation into the contemporaneous state. A delayed variable has a zero row in B and moves only after A propagates the shock. A jump is therefore a timing restriction, not a charting artifact.

A nonzero point at h=0 means the shock changes the plotted variable on impact. It is not the end of a smooth pre-shock segment.

Do not smooth through h=0 when the model says the shock enters contemporaneously.

Decay or hump
rh=aρhorrh=a he−λhρh,∣ρ∣<1r_h=a\rho^h\quad\text{or}\quad r_h=a\,h e^{-\lambda h}\rho^h,\qquad |\rho|<1rh​=aρhorrh​=ahe−λhρh,∣ρ∣<1
ρ\rhoρ

Stable eigenvalues shrink repeated applications of A. If a variable is reached through another state first, the response rises before the stable decay dominates, producing a hump-shaped path.

Post-impact movement follows the model recursion. A hump means delayed propagation, not interpolation by the chart.

Do not treat a hump as evidence of a linear ramp unless the model includes that ramp.

Variable timing

Innovation

ε0≠0,εh=0 for h>0\varepsilon_0\ne 0,\qquad \varepsilon_h=0\ \text{for}\ h>0ε0​=0,εh​=0 for h>0

The shock is dated at horizon zero. A response at h=0 is an impact effect, not the end of a hidden ramp.

State vector

xh=AhBε0x_h=A^hB\varepsilon_0xh​=AhBε0​

A state can move on impact only through the relevant row of B; otherwise it moves after A propagates the shock.

Reported response

rh=CAhBε0+Dεhr_h=CA^hB\varepsilon_0+D\varepsilon_hrh​=CAhBε0​+Dεh​

The plotted variable can jump directly through D or indirectly through the state vector.

Keep going

Read next

Continue with a related concept, model, or example.

DSGE model

Financial Accelerator (BGG)

a contrasting take on Structural VAR

Contrast it →
Theory model

IS-LM Model

a well-connected theoretical model two steps from here

New angle: theoretical model →
Macro by Mark
Hilfe
DatenschutzerklärungNutzungsbedingungenEthik und Compliance

© 2026 Mark Jayson Nation LLC