Zum Hauptinhalt springen

Cookies bei Macro by Mark.Wir verwenden notwendige Cookies für Anmeldung, Sprache und Sicherheit. Mit Ihrer Einwilligung verwenden wir außerdem optionale Cookies für Präferenzen, für Analysen und für Werbemessung mit dem Meta-(Facebook-)Pixel. Lesen Sie unsere Cookie-Richtlinie.

Macro by MarkMacro by Mark
  • Start
Wird geladen …
Wird geladen …
← Modelle
MacroKonzepteWirtschaftspolitikModelle

Bayesian VAR (BVAR) Model

Bayesian shrinkage on a vector autoregression - Minnesota-style priors stabilize forecasts for medium-sized macro systems.

ÜberblickDiagrammMathematikQuellen

Understand the mathematics

Follow the same equations and assumptions one section at a time or in a continuous reading.

Hover or focus a symbol defined in this model to find its exact matches. Select it to keep the highlight; Escape clears the selection.

Reduced-Form Specification and Prior Structure

Write the nnn-variable VAR(p)\text{VAR}(p)VAR(p) in stacked regression form. Let YYY be the T×nT \times nT×n matrix of observations, XXX the T×kT \times kT×k matrix of lagged regressors (k=np+1k = n p + 1k=np+1 including the intercept), and BBB the k×nk \times nk×n coefficient matrix. The model is Y=XB+UY = X B + UY=XB+U, where UUU is T×nT \times nT×n with rows ut′∼N(0,Σ)u_t' \sim N(0, \Sigma)ut′​∼N(0,Σ).

Vectorize: y=vec⁡(Y)y = \operatorname{vec}(Y)y=vec(Y) is Tn×1T n \times 1Tn×1, β=vec⁡(B)\beta = \operatorname{vec}(B)β=vec(B) is kn×1k n \times 1kn×1, and the likelihood is y∣β,Σ∼N((In⊗X)β,Σ⊗IT)y | \beta, \Sigma \sim N((I_n \otimes X) \beta, \Sigma \otimes I_T)y∣β,Σ∼N((In​⊗X)β,Σ⊗IT​). The prior on β\betaβ given Σ\SigmaΣ under the natural conjugate (normal-inverse-Wishart) setup is β∣Σ∼N(b0,Σ⊗Ω0)\beta | \Sigma \sim N(b_0, \Sigma \otimes \Omega_0)β∣Σ∼N(b0​,Σ⊗Ω0​), where b0b_0b0​ is the kn×1k n \times 1kn×1 prior mean and Ω0\Omega_0Ω0​ is a single k×kk \times kk×k prior covariance that the Kronecker structure forces on every equation, up to the Σ\SigmaΣ scaling. This is symmetric cross-shrinkage: the asymmetric Minnesota variance with λcross≠1\lambda_{\text{cross}} \neq 1λcross​=1 cannot be written in the Σ⊗Ω0\Sigma \otimes \Omega_0Σ⊗Ω0​ form.

The Minnesota prior sets specific entries in b0b_0b0​ and Ω0\Omega_0Ω0​. For variable jjj's equation, the prior mean on its own lll-th lag is δj⋅1{l=1}\delta_j \cdot \mathbb{1}\{l=1\}δj​⋅1{l=1} - δj\delta_jδj​ on the first lag only, zero on own lags l≥2l \geq 2l≥2 (δj=1\delta_j = 1δj​=1 for a random-walk variable, 0 for a stationary variable) - and the prior mean on variable kkk's lll-th lag (k≠j)(k \neq j)(k=j) is 0. The prior variance for the (j,k,l)(j, k, l)(j,k,l) coefficient is (λf(j,k)σj/(ldσk))2(\lambda f(j,k) \sigma_j / (l^d \sigma_k))^2(λf(j,k)σj​/(ldσk​))2, where f(j,k)=1f(j,k) = 1f(j,k)=1 if j=kj=kj=k and λcross\lambda_{\text{cross}}λcross​ if j≠kj \neq kj=k, and σj\sigma_jσj​ is the residual standard error from a univariate AR(p)\text{AR}(p)AR(p) for variable jjj.

Y=XB+U,ut∼N(0,Σ)\mathbf{Y} = \mathbf{X}\mathbf{B} + \mathbf{U}, \quad \mathbf{u}_t \sim N(\mathbf{0}, \boldsymbol{\Sigma})Y=XB+U,ut​∼N(0,Σ)
Σ\boldsymbol{\Sigma}Σ

Standard reduced-form VAR in matrix regression form.

y=(In⊗X)β+u,u∼N(0,Σ⊗IT)\mathbf{y} = (\mathbf{I}_n \otimes \mathbf{X})\boldsymbol{\beta} + \mathbf{u}, \quad \mathbf{u} \sim N(\mathbf{0}, \boldsymbol{\Sigma} \otimes \mathbf{I}_T)y=(In​⊗X)β+u,u∼N(0,Σ⊗IT​)
⊗\otimes⊗β\boldsymbol{\beta}βΣ\boldsymbol{\Sigma}Σ

Vectorized form enabling standard Bayesian normal-linear-model machinery.

β∣Σ∼N(b0,Σ⊗Ω0)\boldsymbol{\beta} | \boldsymbol{\Sigma} \sim N(\mathbf{b}_0, \boldsymbol{\Sigma} \otimes \boldsymbol{\Omega}_0)β∣Σ∼N(b0​,Σ⊗Ω0​)
β\boldsymbol{\beta}βΣ\boldsymbol{\Sigma}Σb0\mathbf{b}_0b0​⊗\otimes⊗

Natural conjugate prior. Conditioning on Σ\SigmaΣ makes the posterior tractable.

Var(βj,k,l)={(λld)2if j=k(λ⋅λcrossld⋅σjσk)2if j≠k\text{Var}(\beta_{j,k,l}) = \begin{cases} \left(\dfrac{\lambda}{l^d}\right)^2 & \text{if } j = k \\ \left(\dfrac{\lambda \cdot \lambda_{\text{cross}}}{l^d} \cdot \dfrac{\sigma_j}{\sigma_k}\right)^2 & \text{if } j \neq k \end{cases}Var(βj,k,l​)=⎩⎨⎧​(ldλ​)2(ldλ⋅λcross​​⋅σk​σj​​)2​if j=kif j=k​
λ\lambdaλdddλcross\lambda_{\text{cross}}λcross​

The Minnesota prior variance formula. Own lags get more prior variance (less shrinkage) than cross lags.

Stack the system

Convert the equation-by-equation VAR into a single matrix regression
y=(In⊗X)β+u\mathbf{y} = (\mathbf{I}_n \otimes \mathbf{X})\boldsymbol{\beta} + \mathbf{u}y=(In​⊗X)β+u
⊗\otimes⊗β\boldsymbol{\beta}β

Specify the conjugate prior

Normal-inverse-Wishart is conjugate for the multivariate linear regression model with Gaussian errors
β∣Σ∼N(b0,Σ⊗Ω0),Σ∼IW(S0,ν0)\boldsymbol{\beta}|\boldsymbol{\Sigma} \sim N(\mathbf{b}_0, \boldsymbol{\Sigma} \otimes \boldsymbol{\Omega}_0), \quad \boldsymbol{\Sigma} \sim IW(\mathbf{S}_0, \nu_0)β∣Σ∼N(b0​,Σ⊗Ω0​),Σ∼IW(S0​,ν0​)
β\boldsymbol{\beta}βΣ\boldsymbol{\Sigma}Σb0\mathbf{b}_0b0​⊗\otimes⊗

Run univariate AR(p)\text{AR}(p)AR(p) pre-regressions

The σj\sigma_jσj​ values in the Minnesota variance formula come from residual standard errors of univariate AR(p)\text{AR}(p)AR(p) models for each variable
yj,t=cj+∑l=1pϕj,lyj,t−l+ej,t,σ^j=1T−p−1∑te^j,t2y_{j,t} = c_j + \sum_{l=1}^{p} \phi_{j,l} y_{j,t-l} + e_{j,t}, \quad \hat{\sigma}_j = \sqrt{\frac{1}{T-p-1}\sum_t \hat{e}_{j,t}^2}yj,t​=cj​+l=1∑p​ϕj,l​yj,t−l​+ej,t​,σ^j​=T−p−11​t∑​e^j,t2​​

Construct the prior moments

Build b0b_0b0​ and Ω0\Omega_0Ω0​ from the Minnesota hyperparameters and the AR(p)\text{AR}(p)AR(p) residual standard errors
b0,(j,k,l)={1j=k,l=10otherwise,[Ω0](j,k,l),(j,k,l)=(λ⋅f(j,k)ld⋅σ^jσ^k)2b_{0,(j,k,l)} = \begin{cases} 1 & j=k, l=1 \\ 0 & \text{otherwise} \end{cases}, \quad [\boldsymbol{\Omega}_0]_{(j,k,l),(j,k,l)} = \left(\frac{\lambda \cdot f(j,k)}{l^d} \cdot \frac{\hat{\sigma}_j}{\hat{\sigma}_k}\right)^2b0,(j,k,l)​={10​j=k,l=1otherwise​,[Ω0​](j,k,l),(j,k,l)​=(ldλ⋅f(j,k)​⋅σ^k​σ^j​​)2
λ\lambdaλddd

Write the joint posterior kernel

Combine the likelihood and the prior to form the posterior up to a normalizing constant
p(β,Σ∣Y)∝∣Σ∣−T/2exp⁡(−12(y−Zβ)′(Σ−1⊗IT)(y−Zβ))⋅p(β∣Σ)⋅p(Σ)p(\boldsymbol{\beta}, \boldsymbol{\Sigma} | \mathbf{Y}) \propto |\boldsymbol{\Sigma}|^{-T/2} \exp\left(-\frac{1}{2}(\mathbf{y} - \mathbf{Z}\boldsymbol{\beta})'(\boldsymbol{\Sigma}^{-1} \otimes \mathbf{I}_T)(\mathbf{y} - \mathbf{Z}\boldsymbol{\beta})\right) \cdot p(\boldsymbol{\beta}|\boldsymbol{\Sigma}) \cdot p(\boldsymbol{\Sigma})p(β,Σ∣Y)∝∣Σ∣−T/2exp(−21​(y−Zβ)′(Σ−1⊗IT​)(y−Zβ))⋅p(β∣Σ)⋅p(Σ)
β\boldsymbol{\beta}βΣ\boldsymbol{\Sigma}Σ⊗\otimes⊗

Derive the conditional posterior for β\betaβ

Completing the square in β\betaβ yields a normal distribution
β∣Σ,Y∼N(bˉ,Σ⊗Ωˉ),Ωˉ=(Ω0−1+X′X)−1,bˉ=(Σ⊗Ωˉ)[(Σ⊗Ω0)−1b0+(Σ−1⊗X′)y]\boldsymbol{\beta}|\boldsymbol{\Sigma}, \mathbf{Y} \sim N(\bar{\mathbf{b}}, \boldsymbol{\Sigma} \otimes \bar{\boldsymbol{\Omega}}), \quad \bar{\boldsymbol{\Omega}} = (\boldsymbol{\Omega}_0^{-1} + \mathbf{X}'\mathbf{X})^{-1}, \quad \bar{\mathbf{b}} = (\boldsymbol{\Sigma} \otimes \bar{\boldsymbol{\Omega}})[(\boldsymbol{\Sigma} \otimes \boldsymbol{\Omega}_0)^{-1}\mathbf{b}_0 + (\boldsymbol{\Sigma}^{-1} \otimes \mathbf{X}')\mathbf{y}]β∣Σ,Y∼N(bˉ,Σ⊗Ωˉ),Ωˉ=(Ω0−1​+X′X)−1,bˉ=(Σ⊗Ωˉ)[(Σ⊗Ω0​)−1b0​+(Σ−1⊗X′)y]
β\boldsymbol{\beta}βΣ\boldsymbol{\Sigma}Σ⊗\otimes⊗Ωˉ\bar{\boldsymbol{\Omega}}Ωˉb0\mathbf{b}_0b0​

Interpret the posterior mean as a shrinkage estimator

The Bayesian posterior mean is a matrix-weighted average of the prior mean and the OLS estimate
B^Bayes=ΩˉΩ0−1B0+Ωˉ(X′X)B^OLS\hat{\mathbf{B}}_{\text{Bayes}} = \bar{\boldsymbol{\Omega}}\boldsymbol{\Omega}_0^{-1} \mathbf{B}_0 + \bar{\boldsymbol{\Omega}}(\mathbf{X}'\mathbf{X})\hat{\mathbf{B}}_{\text{OLS}}B^Bayes​=ΩˉΩ0−1​B0​+Ωˉ(X′X)B^OLS​
Ωˉ\bar{\boldsymbol{\Omega}}Ωˉ

Why conjugacy matters

The normal-inverse-Wishart prior is the only prior family for which the multivariate regression posterior is available in closed form. Any other prior - horseshoe, spike-and-slab, non-parametric - requires MCMC or variational approximation.

Notations

⊗\otimes⊗

Kronecker product

IW(S0,ν0)IW(S_0, \nu_0)IW(S0​,ν0​)

Inverse-Wishart prior

Ωˉ\bar{\boldsymbol{\Omega}}Ωˉ

Posterior coefficient covariance

About these symbols

Kronecker product: Kronecker product

Inverse-Wishart prior: Inverse-Wishart distribution with scale S0S_0S0​ and degrees of freedom ν0\nu_0ν0​

Posterior coefficient covariance: Posterior covariance for B (per equation), combining prior and data precision

    Transition checks

    Impact jump
    x0=Bε0,xh=AhBε0(h=1,2,…)x_0=B\varepsilon_0,\qquad x_h=A^hB\varepsilon_0\quad(h=1,2,\ldots)x0​=Bε0​,xh​=AhBε0​(h=1,2,…)

    In a linear state-space representation, B maps the innovation into the contemporaneous state. A delayed variable has a zero row in B and moves only after A propagates the shock. A jump is therefore a timing restriction, not a charting artifact.

    A nonzero point at h=0 means the shock changes the plotted variable on impact. It is not the end of a smooth pre-shock segment.

    Do not smooth through h=0 when the model says the shock enters contemporaneously.

    Decay or hump
    rh=aρhorrh=a he−λhρh,∣ρ∣<1r_h=a\rho^h\quad\text{or}\quad r_h=a\,h e^{-\lambda h}\rho^h,\qquad |\rho|<1rh​=aρhorrh​=ahe−λhρh,∣ρ∣<1
    λ\lambdaλ

    Stable eigenvalues shrink repeated applications of A. If a variable is reached through another state first, the response rises before the stable decay dominates, producing a hump-shaped path.

    Post-impact movement follows the model recursion. A hump means delayed propagation, not interpolation by the chart.

    Do not treat a hump as evidence of a linear ramp unless the model includes that ramp.

    Variable timing

    Innovation

    ε0≠0,εh=0 for h>0\varepsilon_0\ne 0,\qquad \varepsilon_h=0\ \text{for}\ h>0ε0​=0,εh​=0 for h>0

    The shock is dated at horizon zero. A response at h=0 is an impact effect, not the end of a hidden ramp.

    State vector

    xh=AhBε0x_h=A^hB\varepsilon_0xh​=AhBε0​

    A state can move on impact only through the relevant row of B; otherwise it moves after A propagates the shock.

    Reported response

    rh=CAhBε0+Dεhr_h=CA^hB\varepsilon_0+D\varepsilon_hrh​=CAhBε0​+Dεh​

    The plotted variable can jump directly through D or indirectly through the state vector.

    Keep going

    Read next

    Continue with a related concept, model, or example.

    Theory model

    IS-LM Model

    a well-connected theoretical model two steps from here

    New angle: theoretical model →
    Macro by Mark
    Hilfe
    DatenschutzerklärungNutzungsbedingungenEthik und Compliance

    © 2026 Mark Jayson Nation LLC